Hype? The guy is projected as like a 6th-7th round pick. I'd hardly considering that being hyped.
All I'm saying is check out what him and Redman have going. You can't deny the numbers in those 5 weeks. There might be something solid between these 2 guys.
Even if Redman gets sidelined for Matt Ryan, do you think Roddy's numbers would go to trash? He's still the #1 option in the passing game there. He's still going to produce.
If you would happen to own him why not reap the early season benefits of the gel between Redman and White and trade him midseason if you fear Ryan showing up and breaking the marriage?

But that's not the question and doesn't present the answer. Were not asking who the more talented WR is given equal situations. Were looking to answer who will be the most productive in their current situation: a WR who may be the 3rd option overall, but is in a top 5 offense with plenty of scoring ops. Or the top target of his offense, and defensive gameplans, with little help around him on an offense that will likely struggle and be close to the bottom five in offense, meaning limited offensive scoing opportunities.

That are the situations the two face, and flipping them doesn't answer who the best fantasy option is this season.

I'm not saying don't pick White, i actually did select him. But this is what we have to look at.

I deny that Chris Redman is a good NFL QB, I deny that Roddy White will have over 1000 yards receiving, I deny that White will get anywhere near the looks with the new rushing attack, I deny that he will be able to pick up the new offense, I believe that Roddy White=Michael Clayton and I believe that Chris Chambers puts up better numbers this year than White and in fact has a career year. I am done and I can't wait to come back to this thread and point it out to the White Kool-Aid drinkers.

That's cool, as long as you come back if your wrong as well.

Care to place a friendly wager on that?

Absolutely, name the conditions

Im down for standard scoring or PPR.

1 point for every 10 yards, 6 for every TD.

I'm willing to wager however many Vbucks you're willing to lose!!

I'm notorious for losing all of my money but whatever I have come payup time is fair game. We can do PPR for a more realistic representation of their seasons.

Standard or PPR?
How many VBucks?

betting vbucks?

sack up dudes. avatar bet. loser wears it until the 2009 season starts.

Like I said, I'll wager whatever!!

Avatar bet. I say Mustang can design it for the loser. I like his style

You're on Mr Slabaugh

Just locking this bet in.

Dont worry. I will stash this away for the end of week 17